In every Philippine law school, there is one word that sends an immediate chill down a student’s spine during a terrifying recitation: Bagsak. Failed. No partial credit, no sympathy points, try again next semester.
The Classroom Verdict On The Senate Floor
On Day 44 of Vice President Sara Duterte’s Senate impeachment trial, that dreaded classroom verdict echoed across the session hall.
Only this time, it wasn’t a terror professor handing down the sentence. It was the defense’s own expert witness, CPA-lawyer Atty. Rainer Dela Fuente, unwittingly grading himself—and, by extension, the defense team’s entire morning show.
The Unread 50-Page Elephant In The Room
During questioning, Senator-Judge Francis "Kiko" Pangilinan posed a straightforward law school hypothetical: Suppose a professor asks a student to analyze a case governed by proof beyond reasonable doubt, and the student—having never actually read the case—answers purely in hypotheticals.
What grade does that student deserve? Without skipping a beat, Dela Fuente delivered his verdict: Bagsak.
The irony was so thick you could have filed it as an exhibit. Because minutes earlier, Dela Fuente had just admitted that he never actually read Atty. Alexander Cabrera’s 50-page forensic financial report—the very document detailing the ₱817.87 million in alleged unexplained wealth at the heart of Article II.
Throwback Cinema And Political Reruns
Instead of confronting those numbers, the defense turned Dela Fuente’s direct examination into an improvised throwback movie screening.
Defense counsel Mark Vinluan rolled out three archival videos—none of which had anything to do with the Vice President’s unexplained wealth:
The Tears of Renato Corona: First came a lengthy, emotional clip of the late Chief Justice Renato Corona lamenting how impeachment proceedings tormented his family.
It was a textbook appeal to emotion—and a massive strategic own-goal. As Senator Raffy Tulfo and Presiding Officer Chiz Escudero dryly reminded the defense, Corona was convicted for failing to disclose his assets.
Playing the greatest hits of a convicted official is a bold choice when your client is facing the exact same SALN allegations.
The Ghost of Miriam Santiago: Next was a 2012 clip of the late Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago scolding prosecutors for withdrawing articles of impeachment and conducting a "trial by publicity". Never mind that it happened 14 years ago under a different set of senators.
As Senator Erwin Tulfo exasperatedly put it, "We're like watching a movie... let us allow the departed to rest in peace". Worse, as Rep. Chel Diokno and Sen. Risa Hontiveros pointed out, playing clips of the dead is the ultimate hearsay—you can’t cross-examine a ghost.
Dragging Leni Into the Frame: Finally, the defense played an old video of former President Rodrigo Duterte opposing talks of impeaching then-VP Leni Robredo.
Robredo wasn't in the room to state her piece, of course. Coupled with survey numbers showing Sara Duterte polling far ahead of her, the message was unmistakable: the defense wasn't trying to convince the Senator-Judges; they were cutting a 2028 campaign ad for social media.
Heavy Artillery Shooting Blanks
When the popcorn cleared and the spotlight returned to Atty. Dela Fuente, the actual substance didn't fare any better.
Armed with an impressive resume—CPA, lawyer, compliance consultant, and former Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) officer—Dela Fuente was supposed to cast doubt on how quickly the prosecution’s forensic report was finished.
Yet, after calling a two-week financial probe "extremely hard," he conceded on the stand that it was, in fact, "doable" and "possible."
Then Rep. Chel Diokno checked the fine print on Dela Fuente’s credentials, pointing out that his later AMLC stint focused on "Information Campaign Awareness" rather than active financial investigations—and reminding the court that Duterte is on trial for SALN omissions and unexplained wealth, not criminal money laundering.
No Need To Object
To be fair to the defense playbook, lawyers sometimes call narrow-scope witnesses just to discuss general rules and hypotheticals without auditing the opposing side's math. And an impeachment court isn't strictly bound by criminal standards of proof.
Still, whether you are in a law school classroom or on the floor of the Philippine Senate, basic logic refuses to bend: archival clips of dead icons, name-drops of absent rivals, and an expert witness who never read the 50-page report do not erase ₱817.87 million in unexplained wealth.
In the end, Senator Pangilinan didn’t need to cross-examine the witness into a corner. He simply held up a mirror. When asked what happens to someone who shows up to argue a case without reading the material, Atty. Dela Fuente gave the most accurate answer of the entire day.
He called it Bagsak. And for once, the prosecution didn't need to object.
Content & editing put together in collaboration with Google Gemini
Head photo courtesy of Inquirer
Photo app by Canva
Still photos courtesy of Facebook, Inquirer, & Dreamstime

































