Tuesday 7 March 2023

COVID-19 ORIGINS AND ANTI-ASIAN HATE CRIMES: A TALE OF TWO CRISES


 

“Lab leak most likely origin of Covid-19 pandemic, Energy Department now says” (The Wall Street Journal)

“Hate crimes vs. Asian-Americans ‘soaring national crisis’ in US” (Philippine News Agency)

The first headline is about a classified intelligence report provided to the White House and key members of Congress regarding the U.S. Energy Department’s conclusion that the Covid pandemic most likely arose from a laboratory leak.

As the first public confirmation of the FBI’s classified judgment on the Covid-19 origin, FBI chief Christopher Wray told Fox News, “The FBI has for quite some time now assessed that the origins of the pandemic are most likely a potential lab incident.”

Mr. Wray said China “has been doing its best to try to thwart and obfuscate” efforts to identify the source of the global pandemic according to BBC News. In response, Beijing accused Washington of “political manipulation.”

As a backgrounder, the origin of Covid-19 has been a contentious issue since its emergence in late 2019. While the majority of scientists believe that the virus originated from an animal, there is still debate about whether the virus was leaked from a laboratory in China or from the live animal market in Wuhan.

The World Health Organization (WHO) has been investigating the origins of Covid-19 since early 2020. In their initial report, the WHO concluded that it was “extremely unlikely” that the virus originated from a laboratory leak. However, this conclusion was met with skepticism by some scientists and politicians who believe that there is evidence that suggests the virus may have leaked from the Wuhan Institute of Virology located near the live animal market where the first cases of Covid-19 were reported.

The criticisms pressed down the WHO investigation so deep that its director-general has since called for a new inquiry: “All hypotheses remain open and require further study.”



The second headline is about hate crimes against Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders (AAPI) in the US which continue to plague communities across the country.

Philippine News Agency (PNA) reported a high-profile hate crime that took place in Indiana about “an 18-year-old Indiana University student of Asian descent stabbed repeatedly in the head on a city bus because of her race.”

The suspect, Billie Davis, 56, who is white, PNA recounted, “started stabbing the victim in the head with a folding knife as she exited the bus. Davis allegedly told investigators that she stabbed the victim because she was Chinese, saying ‘it would be one less person to blow up our country’.”

“There is fear. Because that could be any of us,” said Rogene Gee Calvert with the nonprofit advocacy group OCA-Greater Houston. He told the PNA:

“I could be sitting in a bus or sitting anywhere and somebody could come up and do something violent to me because they’re angry. It doesn’t matter where we are, who we are, or what we’re doing, but if people have been indoctrinated to believe that we are here to do something wrong, then they will equate whoever they see as Asian as being those people they hate, whether it’s an authoritarian government or country. Their mentality is that we hate those people because we hate those governments.

“I fear the ‘normalization’ of this racial hate and how it has manifested itself through violence. This has become so prevalent in the last five or six years because of the political climate created by the former president (Donald Trump) in which he encouraged and allowed this contempt and hatred to be voiced and accepted.”

In response to the racially-motivated Indiana University attack, PNA reported that the White House announced a multi-agency strategy to help combat anti-Asian American hate, promote language access and improve governmental data collection for the Asian American, Native Hawaiian, and Pacific Islander communities.


As a writer with an engineering background, I’ll put to use some engineering terms by calling the two headlines above “variables” coming into play in our geopolitical world. The “Lab leak” is the “independent variable” – it is the cause. It is “the variable you manipulate (no pun intended) in an experimental study” to explore its effects. Conversely, the “Hate crime” is the “dependent variable” – it is the effect. (There are other effects; I’ll zero in on the “Hate crime.”) Its value depends on changes in the independent variable, “Lab leak.”

To illustrate the relationship: as the “Lab leak” theory of its being true increases, the rate of hate crimes in the US rises, in direct proportion. To weigh up based on how things stack up presently: as the “Lab leak” theory remains in a state of uncertainty, the possibility you’ll be stabbed while sitting in a bus remains chancy. The following headline and its synopsis that seems to jibe with our illustration could give AAPIs the heebie-jeebies:

“The Lab Leak Will Haunt Us Forever” (The Atlantic)

“Each new revelation is a reminder of how little is actually known. The lab-leak theory lives! Or better put: It never dies.”

To those of us, here and now in PH, perhaps, eating our hearts out in joining our loved ones in the land of milk and honey – the USA – the land of the free and the home of the brave, the revealing statements of the Roque family members are a wake-up call, if not words of warning.

In May 2022, the Roque family was waiting in the drive-through line of a McDonald’s when they were verbally and physically assaulted by Nicholas Weber (32, white). Nerissa and Gabriel Roque sustained multiple injuries from the incident, including a broken rib. Weber was charged with felony battery causing serious bodily injury. The following statements were transcribed from Filipino Family Assaulted by White Man at McDonald’s/Sala Talks Unfiltered in YouTube:

GABRIEL: This racism stuff, I knew it was not dead in America, but I didn’t know it was still that very much inherent, but only hidden. I mean, it changed a lot of my perception of what America is actually.

NERISSA: I’m a healthcare worker. I provide care. I give life, I help people. I’m not hurting anyone. And the way I look at America before, I look at them like they’re at the top of the sky. And after this incident, it’s not the way I look at it before.

PATRICIA: Considering how they view America as a whole and how I view things differently from them, I think they did have faith in the legal system, but now they started to see how it actually is for people like us. It does not come as a surprise, but it does give us an experience of what it feels like to be the ones on the receiving end of that system and want the justice and help that we need from them.

PATRICK: The organization that I’m actually volunteering with [that] has helped me the most was the Filipino Migrant Center, as well as the National Alliance for Filipino Concerns (NAFCON). We’re actually able to get pro bono lawyers who were glad to represent us in court free of charge. I encourage you to join these organizations volunteer for the Filipino Migrant Center. It’s not just anti-Asian hate, but the pandemic too. A lot of Filipino workers are actually suffering from poor working conditions, exploitation, and wage theft. The more we raise about it, the more we can bring light to it, and actually do something about it.

Three months ago, I wrote in my ATABAY article “Fresh Perspectives On Twilight Years” the following:

“When will you leave for the US?” My daughter Dionne PMed her Mom.

“Many times before, she raised such a question, bathed with anticipation, right after my wife and I had gotten our visas. We kept on holding off our travel plan due to the hassles of getting ready particularly putting in order what we would leave behind – house, car, and pets, among others – until, double-quick, our plan was shut off by the pandemic.”

Now, that the pandemic seems more manageable, if not over, there and then, pop up the anti-Asian hate crimes. Uh-oh.

Pondering on putting on ice our long-overdue US trip plan, never have I gotten the drift of God’s reassuring words in Jeremiah 29:11 as much as I do today: “For I know the plans I have for you, plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future.”


Head collage photos courtesy of Chinatopix via AP & Jason Leung on Unsplash

No comments:

Post a Comment

USA, HERE WE COME! BELGIUM, AU REVOIR!

  BELGIUM September 1 Discovering Bruges “This is the last city for us to visit.” Mario’s words carried a sense of anticipation as if urging...